The evidence

Does the biodynamic calendar really change how wine tastes?

Does lunar timing change how wine tastes? Explore the tradition, what a blind-tasting study found and a way to compare your own notes.

The claim

Followers of the biodynamic calendar say that on fruit days wines are more expressive, fruity and open, and that on root days they turn closed, earthy and tannic. Some retailers and critics have reportedly scheduled tastings around it.

What the research found

A controlled study was published in PLOS ONE in 2017 by Wendy Parr and colleagues in New Zealand. Nineteen wine professionals tasted twelve Pinot Noirs blind, each wine four times: twice on fruit days and twice on root days. They scored each wine and described it from a list of terms.

The researchers found no consistent support for the predicted Fruit Day advantage. These results did not support the claim that the calendar’s fruit and root categories reliably change the sensory experience of these wines.

Source: Parr, W. V., Valentin, D., Reedman, P., Grose, C. & Green, J. A. (2017). Expectation or sensorial reality? An empirical investigation of the biodynamic calendar for wine drinkers. PLOS ONE 12(1): e0169257.

Why people still swear by it

Try a tasting with the calendar hidden

Ask a host to choose a Fruit session and a Root session using the same calendar and time zone. Tasters should avoid checking the day type until their notes are finished. Dates cannot realistically be hidden, so this is a tasting with the calendar category concealed, not a fully blinded scientific trial.

  1. Use unopened bottles of the same wine and vintage for each session, ideally from the same case. An open bottle kept for another day adds oxidation as a confound; separate bottles still vary.
  2. Keep glassware, serving temperature, pour size, time after opening, food and time of day as similar as possible. Use small tasting pours; spitting is fine.
  3. Have the host cover bottle labels, assign neutral codes and vary the serving order. Include a hidden repeat pour if practical to see how consistent your own scores are.
  4. Write individual notes and a score before discussing the wine. The host records the category and exact local time separately, then reveals them after both sessions.

Wine tasting worksheet

Print this sheet for each taster and session using your browser’s Print command. Choose this section in print selection if supported. No notes are collected or saved by the website.

Taster code: ____________   Session code: ____________

Date and local time: __________________   Time zone: __________________

Serving temperature: ____________   Time since opening: ____________

Food, glassware and conditions: ____________________________________

Sample codeAroma and taste notesEnjoyment, 0–10
A____________________________
B____________________________
C____________________________

Scale: 0 = no enjoyment; 10 = greatest enjoyment. Score before the reveal.

Host’s reveal after both sessions: category ____________   Calendar used ____________

Bottle identities, serving order and repeat sample: ______________________________

Read the results with care

Compare your scores before and after the reveal, including any repeat pours. Bottle variation, storage, order, company and expectations can all change the experience. A small home tasting can reveal your preferences and consistency; it cannot establish a lunar effect. Repeat sessions and keep all the results, including those that do not fit your expectations.

Or let the crowd decide

Moonvine lets you share your tasting experience. Whenever you have a glass, vote tasting great or tasting flat. Your vote counts toward that exact window, alongside everyone else’s. The app shows the crowd’s verdict once that window has at least 10 reports. These self-reported votes reflect individual experiences and expectations; they do not establish that lunar timing changes wine taste.

Questions

Is there scientific evidence for the biodynamic calendar?

For wine tasting, a controlled blind study (Parr et al., PLOS ONE, 2017) did not support the predicted advantage of fruit over root days. Its limited scope cannot settle every claim about wine or agricultural timing.

Why do wine shops use the biodynamic calendar?

Some believe wines show better on fruit and flower days, and choosing a "good" day costs nothing. Expectation may also make tasters more generous.

Keep reading

Share your tasting verdict

Available for iPhone and Android. Vote after a glass and see the crowd’s verdict for the current window.

Explore today’s wine day on the web →